Quantcast

People Horrified By What Oregon Wants To Do To Dogs

Animal rights activists are outraged after an Oregon appeals court issued a controversial ruling on dogs.

The court ordered a couple to stop their Tibetan Mastiff dogs from barking through ‘debarking’ surgery. Labelled as ‘cruel’ and ‘unnecessary’ by such groups, the America Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) has also spoken out against the ruling, stating that the surgery is a “last resort” before euthanasia.

A long-standing feud between neighbors in rural Jackson County, southern Oregon, has resulted in a harsh ruling from a judge in an Oregon appeals court, who ordered a couple with several Tibetan Mastiffs to ‘debark’ their dogs. Debra and Dale Krein, neighbors to the seven dogs, sued couple Karen Szewc and John Updegraff in 2002 for enduring, what they’ve deemed as, years of incessant barking. The “dogs bark[ed] uncontrollably for long periods of time while [Ms. Szewc and Mr. Updegraff were] away from the residence,” court documents state.

After a jury awarded Mr. and Mrs. Krein $238,000 in damages, the Oregon Judge also informed Mrs. Szewc and Mr. Updergraff that all dogs on their property were to undergo “total devocalization” surgery. This cruel surgery, according to the AVMA, involves completely cutting the animals vocal chords, “decreasing the volume, pitch and intensity of the dog’s bark.” While the dogs’ owners have tried to appeal the decision, the Oregon Court of Appeals has upheld the judgement and refused to budge, stating in its 14-page ruling that the lower court had authority to impose the surgery because of the couple’s “persistent failure,” to stop the barking.

The AVMA went on to condemn the procedure, stating that the operation should only be used “as a final alternative to euthanasia,” after every other avenue of remediation has been tried. The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals has also strongly opposed the technique:

“The ASPCA does not support the use of surgical procedures that attempt to circumvent the behavioral issue while exposing pets to unnecessary discomfort and risk.”

The senior director for the Oregon chapter of Humane Society of the United States. Scott Beckstead, told reporters that the “ruling came as a complete shock,” particularly when there are other alternatives to deal with nuisance barking. Ms. Szewc was visibly upset by the ruling, telling newspapers that the pair “do not have the dogs to harass the neighbors,” but use them to guard their flock of sheep. During another dispute in 2005, Jackson County cited Ms. Szewc for violating code provision on public nuisance following complaints that her dogs were allowed to “bark frequently and at length.” Ms. Szewc highlighted that the usual provisions did not apply to her dogs because she owned 3.4-acres of land, where her dogs guarded sheep, goats and chickens. Farms usually fall under different regulations, therefore, Ms. Szewc was able to avoid charges. It is unclear whether the couple, who consider their Mastiffs’ as a part of their family, will attempt to overturn the judgement.

Mike Franell, the attorney of the Kreins, commented on the ruling, stating that the court reached the right decision after his “…clients have suffered well over 10 years of incessant barking.”

Source: Yahoo
Photo: YouTube

Tell Us What You Think

More Fab Stories

Someone attempted to stab a newborn baby to death and left him for dead in a shallow grave in Thailand. Miraculously, the baby was rescued and...

Staff at a hospital in China were shocked when a man brought in his pregnant wife and demanded routine pregnancy exams on her. The girl he...

Windy Pappas, a high school chemistry teacher from California, has been slammed for kneeling while the national anthem was played at her school’s...

It's not easy for mothers of autistic children to make plans. You never know whether your child is going to have a good day, a bad day, or a...

Katie Lehnard, a 31-year-old woman from Petaluma, California, was arrested after she stole credit cards, IDs and check books from the victims of...

Latest Fab Stories

President Trump should look in the mirror when he accuses others of blocking legislation in Congress, according to the Senate’s top-ranking...

A man was left pleasantly surprised by a heart-warming note that was left on his car windscreen after he finished having breakfast with his son at...

One woman was absolutely mortified when she thought a police officer had stopped her for a DUI. As he issued a fake field sobriety test, the...

Authorities are hunting for a 3-year-old girl from Texas after she was reported missing on Saturday morning. The girl was left outside early in...

With all the reports about children dying from being left in hot cars, some parents never learned. Believe it or not, there are still parents who...